Ask a Question

MyCarHelpline Forum for Premium Support !!

Get Professional Support from Experts. Ask your Question Now !!
  Thursday, 16 November 2023
  4 Replies
  502 Visits
I am confused in between Tata Altroz CNG, Tata punch CNG and Hyundai exter all cng cars. Also considering SUV as Tata nexon old shape xm s variant or Brezza Lxi cng.
Gagan Modi changed the title from I am which car to buy in cng under 9lakhs to Confused for Best CNG Car in 9 Lakh — 7 months ago
7 months ago
·
#42379
Dear Abhinav ji,

Greetings !!

1. Tata Motors has CNG in 4 cars
a. Tiago
b. Tigor
c. Punch
d. Altroz

No CNG in Nexon as of now.
There are some differentiation offered by Tata Motors in terms of :- Twin Cylinder which enhance boot space, starting car directly in CNG Mode but biggest issue which remains intact is

> performance : which feels lackluster at 60+ Speed. somehow the CNG Kit is tuned for city use but at higher speed - car performance goes for a toss with substantial slow pickup and would be a slight challenge to overtake

> Noise : Engine is Audible, noisier at times

> Long Term reliability is yet to be proven. Still some minor niggles are there which can be observed.

2. Hyundai CNG has a term where CNG Kit is sourced through external vendor and warranty is provided by CNG Kit Manufacturer and not by Hyundai. Attached confirmation

Best Buy: Maruti CNG Kits are proven and offered the best calibration in terms of Performance, Reliability
There S CNG Kits are proven with time and due to bigger 1.5 Litre Engine which is 4 cylinder one
> More smooth pickup
> Engine Noise, Vibration is much more refined
> 1.5 Litre engine has smooth low end - you get better low end pickup and car pickups in much better way as against Tata Cars - no overtaking issue as such till 80 speed
> Easy Ingress, Egress
> Even end mileage to be slight better too
> Maruti ensure complete ownership of CNG Kit Warranty (and not through CNG Vendor)

Overall from Performance, Reliability, Long term peace of mind - Brezza Lxi CNG is excellent pick. Additionally is a 4 star safety rated car too.

What wont like
> You specified budget of 9 Lakh - somehow Brezza Lxi CNG will cost in almost 10.5 Lakh On Road
> As is basic model - lacks some features and you need to spend slight more for
> Waiting Period is relatively higher

Alternatively - if dont wish to exceed budget too much may even check out :-
a. Fronx Sigma CNG
b. Baleno Delta CNG

Both available at around 9.25 to 9.5 on road (depending on city) and excellent buy basis space, features, performance, reliability too

So overall
First recommendation is Brezza Lxi CNG. But if getting higher waiting or finding too pricey - may check second choice as Baleno Delta CNG or Fronx Sigma CNG
Attachments (1)
7 months ago
·
#42406
Very fair and sensible suggestion admin...thanks but my budget is allowing me wagonr lxi cng variant...however i am not interested because of poorest build quality.. can you share breeza lxi cng users real world mileage?
7 months ago
·
#42413
@ Kartar ji

Expect Brezza to deliver in 18 to 19 kmpl in real world conditions in city use depending on traffic,
while on highway, speed if maintained at 80 - can get close to 23 to 24 kmpl
7 months ago
·
#42420
thanks gagan ji...🙏🏽
  • Page :
  • 1
There are no replies made for this post yet.
Submit Your Response
Upload files or images for this discussion by clicking on the upload button below.
Supported: gif,jpg,png
· Insert · Remove
  Upload Files (Maximum 1MB)
Captcha
To protect the site from bots and unauthorized scripts, we require that you enter the captcha codes below before posting your question.