Welcome to Mycarhelpline Community Blog

Tata Tigor Vs Maruti Swift Dzire. Review Best Buy in Tigor, New Dzire

Tata Tigor Vs Maruti Swift Dzire. Review Best Buy in Tigor, New Dzire

Tata Tigor Comparison against Maruti Swift Dzire. Review Petrol, Diesel Engine Performance with Positives, Negatives, Space, Styling, Safety Features

 

Tata Tigor Vs Maruti Swift Dzire

Its been 5 months since Tigor is launched in Indian Market and has sold close to 13000 Units

Although - the Car looked promising - but the sales from average of 3000 units in March and April has slipped down to sub 2000 units in July. While All New Dzire sold close to 15000 Cars in Single month July. 

But - is Tigor having a Prospect against Dzire

 

Engine Performance, Suspension Dynamics

Although Tata Motors has added up Balancer Shaft in Engine to address on the Vibration issue in Tigor Petrol and yes this certainly has improvised in Tigor Petrol Engine Performance and NVH Levels - but comparing and matching with 4 Cylinder Proven K Series Engine of Maruti Suzuki Swift Dzire would slightly be over-board.

In All New Maruti Dzire- With 4 Cylinder Engine, and Superior Refinement of K Series Engine and build on all New Chassis Platform - Expect Maruti Swift Dzire Petrol has an edge out there. 

Even in DDIS Diesel Engine - with higher Torque, 4 Cylinder Diesel Engine and better Power Output and the fact that Swift Dzire has relatively lower Body Weight delivers it Superior Mid Range Drive-ability, Performance Pep, Noise and Vibration levels superior against Tata Tigor

  Tata Tigor Petrol Maruti Swift Dzire Petrol
Engine 1.2 Litre / 3 Cylinder - 23.84 Kmpl Mileage 1.2 Litre / 4 Cylinder - 22 Kmpl Mileage
Power & Torque 85 PS, 114 NM 84.3 PS, 115 NM
Body Weight 1062 Kg 860 - 895 Kg
Power / Body Weight 80 PS / tonne 98 Ps / tonne
  Tata Tigor Diesel Maruti Swift Dzire Diesel
Diesel Engine 1.05 Litre / 3 Cylinder - 27.28 Kmpl Mileage 1.3 Litre / 4 Cylinder - 28.4 Kmpl Mileage
Power& Torque 70 PS, 140 NM 75 PS, 190 NM
Body Weight 1130 Kg 955 - 990 Kg
Power / Body Weight 61.9 PS / tonne 79 Ps / tonne

 

Steering: Steering Dynamics are at par with Swift Dzire. Light Steering yet Accurate. Though Turning Radius marginally higher at 4.9 m - but the response, thumb contours, Firmness are all good. With the Increased in Speed - the Steering offers good Feedback too

Suspension: Tata Motors Offering in Independent Suspension in Front with Differentiating Factor as Semi Independent Twist Beam with Dual Path Strut. This is what makes Tata Handling on Bad Patch roads as much stable and ease. 

But in City Roads - Maruti Dzire Suspension Dynamics are equally good. 

Only = If you care to drive even on Relative Bad Patch road and that too slight more than often then can accept Tata Tigor turns out to be a serious Contender out there

Convenience of Drive through AMT: If you are some one having Majority of Drive on City Roads - AMT Auto Gear Shift aids on enhanced convenience and certainly Dzire Offers better value proposition by offering AMT in both Petrol and Diesel.

Tata Tigor Front Looks

Maruti Dzire 2017 Looks

 

Body Specs

Although Tata Tigor comes with Improved Boot Space and relative Taller Looks Car

But - its Maruti Suzuki which feels more Spacious in Rear Seat Comfort and due to Wider feels a good spacious Cabin as against Tigor

In Exteriors - though looks can be subjective - but its Dzire which feels more Stylish and Premium especially in Z and Z Plus Trim

  Tata Tigor Maruti Swift Dzire
Length x Width x Height 3992 mm * 1677 mm * 1537 mm 3995 mm * 1735 mm * 1515 mm
WheelBase 2450 mm 2450 mm
Boot Space 419 Lit 378 Lit
Ground Clearance 170 mm 163 mm
Wheels 14 Inch, 15 Inch 14 & 15 Inch

 

 

Maruti Dzire or Tata Tigor

Well Tata Motors has done considerable Job in Offering Tigor as 

» Class Leading Suspension and Class Leading Infotainment System

» Good Appealing Styling with Rear Looks as Wow Factor

» Descent Looking Interiors

» Top Notch Infotainment Sound Quality

 

But its Maruti Dzire which is our Overall Pick as leads 

Maruti Dzire 2017 Interiors

» Engine Refinement in NVH Levels

» Feels more Spacious with Better Legroom on Rear Seat and Rear AC Vents

» Maruti unmatched Reliability with Easy Spare Part Availability

» Feels more Premium in Interiors especially if Top End Zxi Option, Zdi Option

» Superior Mid Range to High Speed Dynamics

» Choice of AMT Auto Gear Shift makes it absolute breeze in City

» Best Selling Compact Sedan Car in India as against Tigor where sales are falling

making Maruti Dzire as overall Pick.

Maruti Ignis Sigma Vs Delta. Zeta Vs Alpha Model D...
Maruti Swift Dzire 2017 Facelift Review. Positives...

Important: If you seek advise or recommendation, pls raise query in Car Forum instead of posting in comments

 

Comments

Have Query, best to raise query in Forum. Else, may add thoughts on the Post as Comment
Guest
Thursday, 24 August 2017